Bhagavan dasa was a prominent figure in the International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON) and served as a zonal acharya. His role involved guiding devotees and overseeing various aspects of the movement.
Controversy and Apology
In 2000, Bhagavan dasa publicly acknowledged a significant error in his leadership. He admitted to assuming the position of initiating diksa guru without proper authorization from Srila Prabhupada, the founder of ISKCON. This unauthorized assumption of authority was recognized by him as his biggest mistake.
Impact on ISKCON
His actions and subsequent apology highlighted ongoing tensions within ISKCON regarding the guru system and the proper procedures for initiating new disciples. Bhagavan dasa's admission reflects the complexities and challenges faced by leaders in the movement, particularly in adhering to the teachings and directives of Srila Prabhupada.
Conclusion
Bhagavan dasa's journey in ISKCON serves as a reminder of the importance of following established protocols and the need for humility in spiritual leadership. His public acknowledgment of mistakes has contributed to discussions about the guru system within ISKCON.
The Gita is very clear as to what qualities a real guru must possess.
Ultimately, Prabhupāda must bear a substantial responsibility for the mess that followed. He created an environment in which extremely immature disciples—many of whom came directly out of the drug culture, the hippie movement, and the social upheaval of the 1960s—were elevated with astonishing speed into positions of spiritual authority. People who had barely begun to understand Vaiṣṇava philosophy, discipline, or sādhana were suddenly dressed in saffron, given Sanskrit names and titles, and placed in positions traditionally associated with years of profound spiritual training.
The result was, in many cases, not the emergence of mature Vaiṣṇavas but the theatrical imitation of Vaiṣṇavism. External symbols were adopted before the internal transformation had taken place. Mundane people were dressed as Vaiṣṇavas, given authority as Vaiṣṇavas, and expected to behave as Vaiṣṇavas, while their consciousness was still deeply conditioned by the very culture from which they had supposedly renounced.
That distinction is crucial. Putting on a dhotī does not make someone a Vaiṣṇava. Shaving the head, accepting daṇḍa, wearing tilaka, receiving a Sanskrit name, or taking sannyāsa does not manufacture spiritual maturity. Yet an entire generation was effectively encouraged to confuse the external costume of renunciation with the substance of renunciation.
The tragedy was not simply that immature individuals failed. Immature individuals can be expected to fail. The deeper problem was that institutional authority was handed to them before they had developed the character, discrimination, knowledge, humility, and spiritual realization required to carry it. Once such people were presented to the public as exalted Vaiṣṇavas, their personal immaturity became an institutional problem.
And this is where Prabhupāda cannot simply be absolved by blaming everything on the later behavior of his disciples. He established the system, appointed the people, and created the expectations under which these developments occurred. Whatever his intentions may have been, the consequences of that system were real.
In effect, a movement that claimed to represent an ancient Vaiṣṇava tradition sometimes became a stage on which Western converts—many still carrying enormous psychological and cultural baggage from the counterculture—performed the role of traditional Vaiṣṇava gurus before they had actually become spiritually qualified to occupy that role.
It was, in many cases, Vaiṣṇava appearance without Vaiṣṇava substance: the costume before the consciousness, the authority before the maturity, and the institution before the realization.
Yes, exactly.
Precisely my experience with these caracters.
Lots of role-playing and parrot-talk, but no substance most of the time.
Also this self proclaimed belief of being better than all the rest of the world, without the real substance to back it up, is nauseating.
Prabhupada definitely had a responsibility there, but he might not have had much of a choice.
Accepting sannyasa at a young age was the last mistake of Bhagavan das. Unfortunately, this was the beginning of the end... As the years went by, he became increasingly arrogant, focusing solely on how to push devotees to bring in more money, and on demonstrating that he was the best among those appointed by Srila Prabhupada to initiate on his behalf. His role within ISKCON was certainly not entirely negative—at a time when Krishna Consciousness needed to be spread throughout the West. Yet, the legacy he left behind here in France, in terms of the movement's public image, has left deep scars that remain visible to this day!
Well, what about all the devotees who were to blind to see what was going on at that time and the years to follow.
His arrogance was impossible to miss, except for his blind followers.
Login
Share videos, music and pictures, follow friends and keep track of what you enjoy!
Background
Bhagavan dasa was a prominent figure in the International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON) and served as a zonal acharya. His role involved guiding devotees and overseeing various aspects of the movement.
Controversy and Apology
In 2000, Bhagavan dasa publicly acknowledged a significant error in his leadership. He admitted to assuming the position of initiating diksa guru without proper authorization from Srila Prabhupada, the founder of ISKCON. This unauthorized assumption of authority was recognized by him as his biggest mistake.
Impact on ISKCON
His actions and subsequent apology highlighted ongoing tensions within ISKCON regarding the guru system and the proper procedures for initiating new disciples. Bhagavan dasa's admission reflects the complexities and challenges faced by leaders in the movement, particularly in adhering to the teachings and directives of Srila Prabhupada.
Conclusion
Bhagavan dasa's journey in ISKCON serves as a reminder of the importance of following established protocols and the need for humility in spiritual leadership. His public acknowledgment of mistakes has contributed to discussions about the guru system within ISKCON.
None of them did.
Its as simple as that.
The result was, in many cases, not the emergence of mature Vaiṣṇavas but the theatrical imitation of Vaiṣṇavism. External symbols were adopted before the internal transformation had taken place. Mundane people were dressed as Vaiṣṇavas, given authority as Vaiṣṇavas, and expected to behave as Vaiṣṇavas, while their consciousness was still deeply conditioned by the very culture from which they had supposedly renounced.
That distinction is crucial. Putting on a dhotī does not make someone a Vaiṣṇava. Shaving the head, accepting daṇḍa, wearing tilaka, receiving a Sanskrit name, or taking sannyāsa does not manufacture spiritual maturity. Yet an entire generation was effectively encouraged to confuse the external costume of renunciation with the substance of renunciation.
The tragedy was not simply that immature individuals failed. Immature individuals can be expected to fail. The deeper problem was that institutional authority was handed to them before they had developed the character, discrimination, knowledge, humility, and spiritual realization required to carry it. Once such people were presented to the public as exalted Vaiṣṇavas, their personal immaturity became an institutional problem.
And this is where Prabhupāda cannot simply be absolved by blaming everything on the later behavior of his disciples. He established the system, appointed the people, and created the expectations under which these developments occurred. Whatever his intentions may have been, the consequences of that system were real.
In effect, a movement that claimed to represent an ancient Vaiṣṇava tradition sometimes became a stage on which Western converts—many still carrying enormous psychological and cultural baggage from the counterculture—performed the role of traditional Vaiṣṇava gurus before they had actually become spiritually qualified to occupy that role.
It was, in many cases, Vaiṣṇava appearance without Vaiṣṇava substance: the costume before the consciousness, the authority before the maturity, and the institution before the realization.
Precisely my experience with these caracters.
Lots of role-playing and parrot-talk, but no substance most of the time.
Also this self proclaimed belief of being better than all the rest of the world, without the real substance to back it up, is nauseating.
Prabhupada definitely had a responsibility there, but he might not have had much of a choice.
Accepting sannyasa at a young age was the last mistake of Bhagavan das. Unfortunately, this was the beginning of the end... As the years went by, he became increasingly arrogant, focusing solely on how to push devotees to bring in more money, and on demonstrating that he was the best among those appointed by Srila Prabhupada to initiate on his behalf. His role within ISKCON was certainly not entirely negative—at a time when Krishna Consciousness needed to be spread throughout the West. Yet, the legacy he left behind here in France, in terms of the movement's public image, has left deep scars that remain visible to this day!
His arrogance was impossible to miss, except for his blind followers.