• Preaching
  • A Christian college student enrolls in a philosophy class with an atheistic Professor. In the first class the Professor demands that all the class members write "God is dead" on a piece of paper and sign it so they can avoid discussing the philosophy of God completely. Everyone, except this one Christian student, signs the paper. But he writes "God's NOT Dead" and then has to prove it.

    when it's coming apart you had it all it wasn't enough no it's not enough they tell you it's not worth the price so just let it go but you know you can find in the world the same just you'll find your way josh whedon you got your pre-registration sheet yeah all core requirements are here What is your humanities elective? Uh, Philosophy 150, Radisson 11, Monday, Wednesday, and Friday. Uh... You might want to think about a different instructor.

    Gus? Let's just say you're wandering into the snake pit. I recommend Patel. Or maybe, uh, Mueller.

    Come on, man, it can't be that bad. Think, uh, Roman Coliseum, lions, people cheering for your death. Yeah, but I'd have to rearrange my whole schedule. I don't think I can really...

    It's your funeral. Last drop date is the 22nd. You might wanna keep that in mind. You're done.

    Thanks. Have a good semester. Hi, I'm Professor Radisson. This is Philosophy 150, Introduction to Philosophical Thought.

    If either of those facts is news to you, then now would be your turn to leave. I understand some of you are here to satisfy your liberal arts elective requirements. If you're looking for an easy grade without much work, Well then, now would be your turn to leave. So you've now enrolled at a university.

    You'll be expected to produce university-level work. I'm out. There's always one. Michel Foucault, Bertrand Russell, Ludwig Feuerbach, Bertrand Brecht, Friedrich Nietzsche, Ayn Rand, George Santayana, Democritus, Denis Diderot, David Hume, John Stuart Mill, Albert Camus, Richard Dawkins, Sigmund Freud, Noam Chomsky, and the list goes on. philosophers, poets, scientists, authors, towering intellects, all of them.

    But what do they all have in common? Yes. They're all dead. Well, that would be incorrect.

    Mr. Dawkins and Mr. Chomsky are still very much alive. Mr.

    G-dogged Rod Trigger. G-dogged. Anyone else? Well, they are, or were, atheists.

    Based on the 16th century French atheisme, from the Greek theos, meaning God, and from the prefix a, meaning as it always does in Greek, without, in short, each of the thinkers I named took the strong position that there is no God, as opposed to the weak position of agnosticism, gnostic from the Greek gnosos, to know, and again with the prefix a, meaning to not know, or more accurately, to doubt the existence of a supreme being. This semester I propose that we refuse to waste our limited time together debating the existence of the big man in the sky, the myth of a benevolent, all-powerful, supernatural being. God is dead. This is, of course, a metaphor, but an illustrative one, meaning not that God has somehow died, but rather that he never existed in the first place.

    Other than in the depths of our forebears' imaginations, he was a useful fairy tale in ages gone by, when his fiery anger was used to explain away plagues and crop failures, diseases and disasters, which we now ascribe to bacteria and viruses, chromosomal disorders and plate tectonics. In short, science and reason have supplanted superstition, and we are all the better for it. And with your permission, I would like to bypass this senseless debate altogether and jump to the conclusion, which every sophomore is already aware of, there is no God. All that I require from each of you is that you fill in the papers I've just given you with three little words, God is dead, along with your signature, assuming we reach a unanimous consensus, which I expect we will.

    I will be spared the tedious duty of slogging through dry, industrious arguments, and you will bypass the section of the course in which students have traditionally received their lowest grades of the semester. And when you finish, please pass your papers to the right. A lowercase g. Maybe this one ought to get extra credit.

    Thank you. Excuse me, Mr... Wheaton. Josh Wheaton.

    Mr. Wheaton, is something wrong? Yeah, I can't. I can't do what you want, Mr.

    Christian. Oh, don't worry. You can still go back to your dorm room and sink to your knees and pray at your bedside if you'd like. What you do in your personal life is your business, but what you do in this class is mine.

    Allow me to explain the alternative. If you cannot bring yourself to admit that God is dead for the purposes of this class, then you will need to defend the antithesis that God is not dead, and you'll need to do it in front of this class from the podium. And if you fail, as you shall, you will fail this section and lose 30% of your final grade right off the bat. Are you ready to accept that?

    Well, who would decide whether I won or lost the argument? Well, I would. It's not my class, my rules. Grading is my prerogative.

    No disrespect, but I'm not sure you can be objective. Would you propose? What about them? That's interesting, but why would I want to empower them?

    Well, you've already won them over. I mean, I'd have to unconvince them. Get them to admit they were wrong. All right, Mr.

    Wheaton. You'll get three sessions, the last 20 minutes of each of the next three classes to make your case. I promise to keep my interruptions to a minimum. You may take whatever questions you'd like from the class, but it will not increase your allotted time.

    Of course, you'll be responsible for all the other class assignments. But, you know, you could change your mind and bring in your signed statement at our next class, and we'll go forward as though none of this ever happened. The rest of us, having dispensed with primitive superstition, and we'll turn our focus to the issue of being in reality. For our next class, please have read David Hume's The Problems of Induction, Rene Descartes' Discourse on Method, which you may add Bertrand Russell's Why I Am Not a Christian in preparation for Mr.

    Wheaton's lecture. And thanks for his failure to help us reach a unanimous consensus. You don't want to deny your faith. I get it.

    So the answer's simple, drop the class. Yeah, but I'm not sure I can do that. I feel like God wants someone to defend him. Don't be ridiculous.

    I just keep thinking of that C.S. Lewis line. Only a real risk tests the reality of the league. So you're gonna risk our future over your yearbook quote?

    Josh, why am I here? Hello? Earth to Josh. Why am I salutatorian of our graduating class here at my third choice school?

    I'm sorry for having the next 50 years our life planned out that's just who i am i don't care it's just josh i love you but i absolutely forbid you to go up against a professor in his own classroom we have too much at stake the whole thing's rigged to make you look like an idiot if you want to get into law school you can't afford to flunk this class even a c could be disastrous can i help you you uh you waiting for someone yeah you could say that it looks like he's out at the moment well maybe that's why he sent me I could drop the class, run away, pretend like it never happened, which is what my girlfriend wants. I could sign the paper saying something I don't believe. Or I could commit academic suicide in front of a live audience by trying to prove that God exists.

    How many people in that class? Eighty, maybe. And how many of them do you think would ever step foot in here or any other church for that matter? Well, none, probably.

    So your acceptance of this challenge, if you decide to accept it, may be the only meaningful exposure to God and Jesus they'll ever have. Yeah. Yeah, I suppose so. Check out Matthew 10, 32 and 33.

    That's it? That's all? Yeah. Just a scriptural citation?

    If you're still undecided after that one, look at Luke 12, 48. It can't be that simple. Sure it can. You're here because that still small voice inside you isn't happy with the choices everyone else wants you to make.

    Personally, I think it's the Holy Spirit talking to you. It's how he interacts with us if we allow him to. All you have to do is decide whether or not you're willing to listen. It's not easy, but it's simple.

    Everyone who acknowledges me before men, I also will acknowledge before my Father who is in heaven. Whoever denies me before men, I also will deny before my Father who is in heaven. everyone to whom much was given of him much will be required and from him to whom they entrusted much they will demand them more babe where have you been did you turn your phone off more like i forgot to turn my phone on do you know what day it is thursday anything else the 13th happy anniversary six years ago your youth group collided with mine You remembered. Mm-hmm. And we're gonna celebrate.

    You remember how we met? These boys. They're gonna be in town next Friday. You are amazing.

    Which is why I love you. Mm-hmm. Look, I know I came off probably way too strong yesterday. You know, I just...

    I get concerned when outside things start coming between us. You get that, can't you? Sure. You're good, man.

    Always. Come on. well that can't all be statistics josh please tell me you haven't been spending all your time on that philosophy thing not all of it okay most of it josh that's not funny it's really not look this is something i want to do okay i don't understand how it comes between us josh everything you do is about us okay we're a team i mean we're what six years going on forever, right? It means your grades, your whole future. Yeah, I'm a part of that.

    I don't see how this is contributing to our future. Yeah, well, neither do my parents or anyone else in my life. What should that tell you if every single person that loves you is saying the exact same thing? Josh, I'm letting you know now for your own good.

    This experiment is over. You need to prioritize and decide who's the most important person in your life. Me? Professor Radisson.

    What if it's God? God wants you with me. So it's the same answer. Just return the book to the library, sign the stupid paper, and move on.

    A year from now, we'll look back on this and laugh. We're not in high school anymore. The decisions you make now have real consequences. Josh, Josh, this is serious.

    No. Flat earthers out there who still consider the existence of a supreme deity to be either necessary or self-evident, or both. And with that, as previously announced, I will be turning the podium over to Mr. Wheaton, who will be presenting his case in favor of a supreme celestial dictator otherwise known as God.

    Mr. Wheaton, are you ready? Podium is yours. Atheists say that no one can prove the existence of God, and they're right. but I say no one can disprove that God exists.

    But the only way to debate this issue is to look at the available evidence and that's what we're going to do. We're going to put God on trial with Professor Radisson as the prosecutor, me as the defense attorney, and you as the jury. Most cosmologists now agree that the universe began some 13.7 billion years ago in an event known as the Big Bang. So let's look at theoretical physicist and Nobel Prize winner Steven Weinberg's description of what the Big Bang would have looked like, and since he's an atheist, we can be sure there isn't any believer bias in his description.

    In the beginning there was an explosion, and in three minutes, 98% of the matter there is or ever will be was produced. We had a universe. For 2,500 years, most scientists agreed with Aristotle on the idea of a steady-state universe, that the universe has always existed with no beginning and no end. But the Bible disagreed.

    In the 1920s, Belgian astronomer George Le Maître, a theist, who's actually also... What's a theist? A theist is someone who believes in the existence of God. He said that the entire universe, jumping into existence in a trillionth of a trillionth of a second, out of nothingness, in an unimaginably intense flash of light, is how he would expect the universe to respond if God were to actually utter the command in Genesis 1-3, let there be light.

    In other words, the origin of the universe unfolded exactly how one would expect after reading Genesis, and for 2,500 years, the Bible had it right, and science had it wrong. It's all part of his grand design. All of which points to a God that created it. You see, in the real world, we never see things jumping into existence out of nothingness, but atheists want to make one small exception to this rule, namely the universe and everything in it.

    But in his book, The God Delusion, Richard Dawkins says that if you tell me God created the universe, then I have the right to ask you who created God. Dawkins' question only makes sense in terms of a God who has been created, it doesn't make sense in terms of an uncreated God, which is the kind of God that Christians believe in. And even leaving God out of the equation, I then have a right to turn Mr. Dawkins' own question back around on him and ask, if the universe created you, then who created the universe?

    You see, both the theist and the atheist are both burdened with answering the same question of how did things start. What I'm hoping you'll pick up from all this is that you don't have to commit intellectual suicide to believe in a creator behind the creation. And to the extent that you don't allow for God, you'd be pretty hard-pressed to find any credible alternative explanation for how things came to be. Well, I imagine you're quite pleased with yourself.

    I see you've carefully avoided the fact that Stephen Hawking, the world's most famous scientist and who is not a theist, has recently come out in favor of a self-designing universe. I haven't avoided it, I just didn't... You just didn't know about it. All right.

    Well, let's see what Professor Hawking, the occasion professor of physics at Cambridge who occupies a teaching chair once held by Sir Isaac Newton, has to say about the origin of the universe. And I quote, Because there's a law such as gravity, the universe can and will create itself from nothing. Spontaneous creation is the reason there is something instead of nothing. It's why the universe exists, why we exist.

    It is not necessary to invoke God to set the universe in motion. End quote. So you may have never come across this comment, but this point remains. How do you answer it?

    I don't know. You don't know. I prick the balloon of your entire argument with a single pen, and you don't know. Huh.

    Well, I mean, I'd like to tell you I have the perfect answer, but it doesn't shake my underlying faith. Okay. So the greatest scientific mind in all of history says that God is not necessary, but a first semester freshman says, oh, yes, he is. Wow.

    You know, it's going to be a really tough choice. Well, I look forward to next week's lecture. Class is dismissed. Do you think you're smarter than me, Wheaton?

    Do you think there's any argument you can make that I won't have an answer for? I never said I was smarter. That's the first intelligent thing who said, make this clear, in that classroom, there is a God, and yet I'm him. I'm also a jealous God, so do not try to humiliate me in front of my students.

    You know, I also checked up on your declared major one, pre-law. What exactly is pre-law? We don't award degrees on that. Don't bother answering.

    But know this, if you truly feel a need to continue with this charade, I will make it my personal mission to destroy any hope of a law degree in your future. Have a nice day. You did it, didn't you? What?

    You know what I'm talking about. You went and did your argument, didn't you? Yeah. Yeah, I did.

    What were you trying to prove? I'm not even sure there are words to describe what I'm feeling right now. I'm sorry, Josh, but it's over between us. That's it?

    It's just, it's over? It's over, Josh. If you're going to do something this stupid and selfish after I already told you what would happen... Yeah, but that's sort of the point, isn't it?

    This is something that's important to me. But since it's not important to you, you made it a make-it-or-break-it thing for us. You didn't ask me. You told me.

    It wasn't a decision that we made. It was a decision that you made for the both of us. Somebody had to. That's it?

    Okay? It's not what I want. Honestly, I'm still hoping you'll change your mind. But I have to do this thing.

    I feel like it's something that God wants me to do. I can't just turn away from it. Especially not now, now that I've started. My mother was so right about you.

    I just wish I'd had the sense to listen. Uh, you're my philosophy class. Martin, right? Correct.

    Um, and you're Mr. Josh? Yeah. Yeah, that's me.

    Mr. Josh. Hey, is that on our reading list? Um, no.

    Can I ask you a question? Yeah, sure. Uh, why are you doing what you are doing? Everyone else thinks I'm crazy. girlfriend, ex-girlfriend left me over it.

    My parents don't want me to risk it. At the end of it all, I'm going to have to work like a dog for the rest of the semesters to catch up on my other classes. You have to describe your difficulties, but you haven't answered my question of why. I don't know, I just think of Jesus as my friend.

    So, you think Jesus is God? Yeah, I'm the son of God. I don't want to disappoint him, even if everyone else thinks I should. See, to me, he's not dead.

    He's alive. I don't want anyone to get talked out of believing in him just because some professor thinks they should. See you around, Martin. Bye.

    In our last class, I was asked a question that I couldn't answer. Um, as Professor Radisson pointed out, Stephen Hawking is an atheist. He also wrote a book called The Grand Design in which he says the following. Because there's a law such as gravity, the universe can and will create itself from nothing.

    And to be honest, I tend not to refute that. I mean, after all, Hawking is clearly a genius. But, Professor John Lennox, who teaches mathematics and philosophy, has demonstrated that there are not one, even two, but three errors of logic contained in that one simple sentence, and it all boils down to circular reasoning. Hawking is basically saying that the universe exists because the universe needed to exist and because the universe needed to exist it therefore created itself.

    It's like this. If I say to you that I can prove that Spam is the best tasting food that's ever existed because in all of history no food has ever tasted better, you'd probably look at me strange and say I haven't proven anything and you'd be right. All I've done is restate my original claim. But when Hawking claims that the universe created itself because it needed to create itself and then offers that as an explanation as to how and why it was created, we don't immediately recognize that he's doing the same thing.

    But he is, prompting Lennox to further comment, nonsense remains nonsense even when spoken by famous scientists, even though the general public assumes they're statements of science. This is the height of hubris. Are you telling me that you, a freshman, are saying that Stephen Hawking is wrong? No.

    What I'm saying is that John Lennox, a professor of mathematics and philosophy, has found Professor Hawking's reasoning to be faulty, and I agree with his logic. But if you can't bear to disagree with Hawking's thinking, then I suggest that you turn to page 5 of his book, where he insists philosophy is dead. And if you're so sure of Professor Hawking's infallibility, and philosophy really is dead, then, well, there's really no need for this class. it's like i'm a convenience to him except for when my faith comes up then he becomes verbally abusive i'm guessing he's bright brilliant handsome yes and his attention makes you feel special gives you a sense of completeness have you been reading my diary psychologists call it the cinderella complex it's not my name for it so don't get upset with me guys are capable of the same thing it's just they don't have a name for it but in essence you're looking for his approval to give you a sense of self-worth instead of generating it internally don't most people do that yeah a lot of people do sure but using romance to shore up self-image is an unstable foundation do you believe god's capable of error bias or bad judgment no so if he's incapable of mistakes and he made you in his likeness and image and it follows that he cares about you right right to the point where god's only son would willingly be crucified again for you just you if that's what was necessary well if he loves you that much who cares what your boyfriend thinks to the wrong person you'll never you'll never have any worth but to the right person you mean everything.

    Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, for the last 150 years, Darwinists have been saying that God is unnecessary to explain man's existence and that evolution replaces God. But evolution only tells you what happens once you have life. So where did that something that's alive come from? Well, Darwin never really addressed it.

    He assumed maybe some lightning hit a stagnant pool full of the right kind of chemicals. Bingo! A living something. But it's just not that simple.

    You see, Darwin claimed that the ancestry of all living things came from that one, single, simple organism, which reproduced and was slowly modified over time into the complex life forms we view today. Which is why, after contemplating his own theory, Darwin uttered his famous statement, Natura non facit solta, meaning, nature does not jump. Well, as noted, author Lee Strobel pointed out that if you can picture the entire 3.8 billion years, that scientists say life has been around, is one 24-hour day. In the space of just about 90 seconds, most major animal groups suddenly appear in the forms of which they currently hold, not slowly and steadily, as Darwin predicted, but in evolutionary terms, almost instantly.

    So, nature does not jump, becomes, nature makes a giant leap. Did Thetis explain this sudden outburst of new biological information? And God said, Let the water team with living creatures and let birds fly above the earth across the expanse of the sky. So God created the great creatures of the sea and every living and moving thing with which the water teams according to its kind.

    And God saw that it was good. Genesis 1.20 In other words, creation happened because God said it should happen. And even what looks to our eyes to be a blind, unguided process could really be divinely controlled from start to finish. No.

    It's easy to dismiss what you don't understand, or what you don't want to understand. There it is. The default setting of the Bible thumper. If only you would open the scripture and read, then you would understand.

    So says the brave young freshman. For thou art wise, and with thou all wisdom shall die. Job 12, verse 2. What else does Job tell us?

    For man who was born of woman is few of days and full of trouble. He comes forth like a shadow and does not continue. So man lies down and does not rise till the heavens are no more. Well, at least he got that part right.

    When a 12-year-old watches his mother dying of cancer, it's only natural to beg God for her life. And he'll promise anything to his make-believe grandfather in the sky, including to love and worship him forever. if only he will spare her? Sometimes the answer is no. Tell that to me the day you lose someone you love.

    She died believing a lie. She died believing that someone out there loved her even while he was strangling her to death. God who would allow that is not worth believing in. That is why, Wheaton, you will find the most committed atheists were once Christians.

    But we took the blinders off. We saw the world for what it truly is. You see, Shakespeare had it right. Life is really a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury and signifying nothing.

    I made a mistake with you, letting you speak in front of my classroom and spew your propaganda. And today, we're gonna change things up a bit. It's been said that evil is atheism's most potent weapon against the Christian faith, and it is. After all, the very existence of evil begs the question, If God is all good and God is all powerful, why does he allow evil to exist?

    The answer at its core is remarkably simple, free will. God allows evil to exist because of free will. From the Christian standpoint, God tolerates evil in this world on a temporary basis so that one day those who choose to love him freely will dwell with him in heaven, free from the influence of evil, but with their free will intact. In other words, God's intention concerning evil is to one day destroy it.

    Well, how convenient. One day, I will get rid of all the evil in the world. But until then, you just have to deal with all the wars and holocausts, tsunamis, poverty, starvation, and AIDS. Have a nice life.

    Next, you'll be lecturing us on moral absolutes. Well, why not? Professor Radisson, who's clearly an atheist, doesn't believe in moral absolutes. But his course syllabus says he plans to give us an exam during finals weeks.

    Now, I'm betting that if I manage to get an A in the exam by cheating, he'll suddenly start sounding like a Christian, insisting it's wrong to cheat, that I should have known that. And yet, what basis does he have? If my actions are calculated to help me succeed, then why shouldn't I perform them? For Christians, the fixed point of morality, what constitutes right and wrong, is a straight line that leads directly back to God.

    Oh, so you're saying that we need a God to be moral, that a moral atheist is an impossibility. No, but with no God, there's no real reason to be moral. I mean, there's not even a standard of what moral behavior is. For Christians, lying, cheating, stealing, in my example, stealing a great I didn't earn, are forbidden.

    It's a form of theft, but if God does not exist, as Dostoevsky famously pointed out, If God does not exist, then everything is permissible. And not only permissible, but pointless. If Professor Radisson is right, then all of this, all of our struggle, our debate, whatever we decide here is meaningless. I mean, our lives and ultimately our deaths have no more consequence than that of a goldfish.

    Come on, this is ridiculous. So after all your talk, you're saying that it all comes down to choice. Believe or don't believe. That's right.

    That's all there is. That's all there's ever been. The only difference between your position and my position is that you take away their choice. You demand that they choose the box marked, I don't believe.

    That's because I want to free them. Because religion is like a... It's like a mind virus that parents have passed on down to their children. And Christianity is the worst virus of all.

    It slowly creeps into our lives when we're weak or sick or helpless. So religion is like a disease? Yes. Yes, it infects everything.

    It's the enemy of reason. Reason? Professor, you left reason a long time ago. What you're teaching here isn't philosophy.

    It's not even atheism anymore. What you're teaching is anti-theism. It's not enough that you don't believe. You need all of us to not believe with you.

    Why don't you admit the truth? You just want to ensnare them in your primitive superstition. What I want is for them to make their own choice. That's what God wants.

    You have no idea how much I'm going to enjoy failing you. Yeah, but who are you really looking to fail? professor me or God do you hate God it's not even a question okay why do you hate God this is ridiculous why do you hate God answer the question you've seen the science and the arguments science supports his existence you know the truth so why do you hate him why simple question professor why did you hate God Because he took everything away from me. Yes, I hate God. All I have for him is hate.

    How can you hate someone if they don't exist? Maybe not. They get to choose. Is God dead?

    God is not dead. God's not dead. God's not dead. God's not dead.

    God's not dead. God's not dead. God's not dead. God's not dead.

    God's not dead. God's not dead. God's not dead. Josh!

    Josh! Josh! Your decision to prove God is not dead has affected me greatly. I'm glad.

    Yes, and it has changed everything. I've decided to follow Jesus. That's great, Martin. Hey, you know what?

    You gotta check this out. Okay. My dearest son, words cannot express the love I have for you or the sorrow in my heart knowing that I will never be able to see you grow up and fulfill God's plan for your life. My heart is broken at the thought of leaving you.

    I know God is in control. His ways are higher than our ways, and His thoughts are higher than our thoughts. Live life to the fullest and remain in the joy of the Lord. You will forever be in my heart.

    I love you. It's a cause for celebration. Pain, yes, for just a few moments. But now, think about the joy.

    0 Comments